\n
\n

What is the best payment gateway for e-commerce in the United States in 2025?

Honest and complete analysis of the top 8 gateways in the US market

💡 Quick Answer

There is no single "best" gateway. The choice depends on your business:

Pro Tip: Always have 2 gateways to never lose sales if one goes down!

📊 Complete Comparison Table - Top 8 Gateways

Gateway Transaction Fee Monthly Fee Setup Fee ACH/Bank Approval Time
Stripe 2.9% + $0.30 $0 $0 0.8% ($5 cap) Instant
PayPal 2.99% + $0.49 $0 $0 Not available Instant
Square 2.9% + $0.30 $0 $0 1% ($1 min) Instant
Authorize.Net 2.9% + $0.30 $25 $0 $0.75 1-2 days
Braintree 2.59% + $0.49 $0 $0 0.75% ($5 cap) 2-3 days
2Checkout 3.5% + $0.35 $0 $0 Not available 2-5 days
Helcim 1.93% + $0.08 $0 $0 $0.25 1-2 days
Adyen 0.6% + $0.12 Custom Custom $0.60 5-10 days

⚠️ Important: Base rates for reference. Higher volumes allow negotiation.

🏆 Detailed Analysis of Top 8 Gateways

Best for Developers

✅ Pros

  • Best API & docs
  • Instant approval
  • 135+ currencies
  • Subscription tools
  • Fraud protection

❌ Cons

  • Non-negotiable rates
  • Limited phone support
  • Complex for beginners
  • Account freezes

Ideal for: SaaS, subscriptions, developers, API-first businesses.

Most Trusted

✅ Pros

  • Customer trust
  • 200+ countries
  • One-click checkout
  • Buyer protection
  • No monthly fees

❌ Cons

  • Higher fees
  • Fund holds
  • Seller bias
  • Difficult disputes

Ideal for: International sales, customer trust priority.

✅ Pros

  • All-in-one solution
  • Free POS system
  • Next-day deposits
  • Inventory management
  • Easy setup

❌ Cons

  • Account terminations
  • Limited customization
  • Basic API
  • US-focused

Ideal for: Small businesses, retail + online combo.

✅ Pros

  • 25+ years trusted
  • Advanced features
  • Recurring billing
  • Fraud suite
  • Phone support

❌ Cons

  • $25 monthly fee
  • Dated interface
  • Setup complexity
  • Higher total cost

Ideal for: Established businesses, B2B transactions.

✅ Pros

  • PayPal owned
  • Venmo integration
  • Lower rates
  • Global reach
  • Mobile SDKs

❌ Cons

  • Developer focused
  • Manual underwriting
  • Complex setup
  • Limited support

Ideal for: Mobile apps, marketplaces, high volume.

✅ Pros

  • 200+ countries
  • 45+ currencies
  • Tax management
  • Subscription tools
  • Digital goods focus

❌ Cons

  • Higher fees
  • Rolling reserves
  • Complex pricing
  • Account holds

Ideal for: Global digital sales, SaaS, software.

✅ Pros

  • Lowest rates
  • Volume discounts
  • No monthly fees
  • Transparent pricing
  • Great support

❌ Cons

  • US/Canada only
  • Smaller company
  • Basic features
  • Limited integrations

Ideal for: Cost-conscious businesses, transparent pricing seekers.

✅ Pros

  • Enterprise grade
  • Lowest IC++ rates
  • 250+ payment methods
  • Risk management
  • Omnichannel

❌ Cons

  • High minimums
  • Enterprise focus
  • Complex pricing
  • Long approval

Ideal for: Enterprise, $1M+ annual volume.

💰 Fee Calculator - $10,000/month Simulation

Base: 80% credit cards, 15% digital wallets, 5% ACH

Stripe
$310
PayPal
$348
Square
$310
Authorize.Net
$335
Braintree
$308
Helcim
$201

💡 Maximum annual savings: $1,764 (choosing Helcim vs PayPal)

🎯 Decision Guide by Business Profile

🌱 Just Starting Out?

Choose: Stripe + Square

  • Instant approval, no paperwork
  • Ready-to-use checkout
  • No monthly fees
  • Having 2 options = never lose a sale

📈 Growing Business?

Choose: PayPal + Authorize.Net

  • Customer trust + advanced features
  • Better for B2B transactions
  • Recurring billing tools
  • Phone support available

🏢 High Volume/Enterprise?

Choose: Negotiate with Braintree/Adyen

  • Custom rates by volume
  • Dedicated account manager
  • Custom contracts
  • Can reach 1.5% on credit

🌍 International Sales?

Choose: PayPal + Stripe

  • Accepted worldwide
  • Multi-currency native
  • Currency protection
  • Customers trust more

🔧 Integration and Features Comparison

Feature Stripe PayPal Square Authorize.Net
REST API ✅ Excellent ✅ Good ✅ Good ✅ Basic
Webhooks ✅ Perfect ✅ Reliable ✅ Reliable ⚠️ Limited
Mobile SDKs ✅ ✅ ✅ ✅
Digital Wallets ✅ All major ✅ Limited ✅ Apple/Google ✅ Apple/Google
ACH/Bank ✅ ❌ ✅ ✅
Subscriptions ✅ Advanced ✅ Basic ✅ Basic ✅ Advanced
Marketplace ✅ Connect ✅ Commerce ❌ ❌
Fraud Protection ✅ Radar ✅ Basic ✅ Basic ✅ Advanced

💸 Hidden Costs Nobody Talks About

⚠️ Watch Out for Extra Fees!

Beyond basic rates, consider:

✅ Industry Best Practices

  1. Always use 2 gateways: Primary + backup (avoid lost sales)
  2. Negotiate after 6 months: With history, get better rates
  3. Monitor chargebacks: Above 1% causes problems
  4. Test before launch: Simulate all possible scenarios
  5. Set up webhooks: Essential for reliable automation
  6. Document everything: Screenshots help in disputes
  7. Enable fraud tools: Better to decline than chargeback
  8. Offer multiple options: Cards, wallets, ACH, BNPL

🔄 How to Switch Gateways (Without Losing Sales)

Safe Step-by-Step Process:

  1. Implement new in parallel: Don't turn off old one yet
  2. Test with 10% traffic: Use A/B test for 15 days
  3. Migrate subscriptions slowly: 20% per week
  4. Export all data first: Keep complete history
  5. Notify saved customers: Email about new checkout
  6. Monitor metrics: Conversion rate should maintain
  7. Have rollback ready: If something fails, revert fast

🏆 Converso.pro Final Recommendation

Our Honest Suggestion:

For 90% of US e-commerce businesses:

  1. Start with: Stripe (primary) + Square (backup)
  2. At 6 months: Add PayPal for customer trust
  3. At $50k+/month: Negotiate with Braintree for lower rates
  4. Always: Offer digital wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay)

Ready to Set Up Your Payment Gateways?

Converso.pro integrates with all major US payment gateways

Create Free Store View Integrations

✓ 5-minute setup   ✓ Multiple gateways   ✓ Optimized checkout